2026 Comparison
DIY Stump Removal vs Professional Grinding
Compare hiring a stump grinder yourself versus booking a professional stump grinding company — true cost, safety, equipment limitations, and which approach delivers better value.
Winner
All Stumps Removed
Best overall option once average cost, coverage, and support reputation are weighed together.
Average Gap
$195
Difference in average pricing across overlapping stump grinding services.
Market Range
$48 - $640
The full low-to-high range across both providers.
Brisbane, QLD · Est. 2003
From
$48
Average
$101
Coverage
8 areas
Best for: Property managers, developers, and homeowners with multiple stumps who want the best bulk discount rates and a complete service including backfill and levelling.
Review All Stumps RemovedMelbourne, VIC · Est. 1994
From
$110
Average
$296
Coverage
9 areas
Best for: Homeowners wanting a nationally recognised brand with a satisfaction guarantee, wide geographic coverage, and the convenience of a single operator for both tree removal and stump grinding.
Review Jim's TreesSide-by-Side Price Comparison
Compare overlapping service types directly so the right price anchor is clear before you request quotes.
| Service | All Stumps Removed | Jim's Trees | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small Stump Grinding (under 30cm) | $140 | $160 | -$20 |
| Multiple Stumps (2–5 stumps) | $105 | N/A | - |
| Multiple Stumps (6+ stumps) | $82 | N/A | - |
| Backfill and Level (soil + turf-ready) | $78 | N/A | - |
| Medium Stump Grinding (30–60cm) | N/A | $250 | - |
| Large Stump Grinding (60–100cm) | N/A | $375 | - |
| Emergency / Same-Day Removal | N/A | $400 | - |
Pros & Cons
All Stumps Removed
WinnerPros
- ✓Best multiple stump discount rates in the market
- ✓Strong backfill and levelling package included as an option
- ✓Good coverage across multiple capitals and regional centres
Cons
- ✗Less suited for single large or emergency stumps where specialists are faster
- ✗Franchise quality can vary by operator region
Jim's Trees
Pros
- ✓Largest national stump grinding network with metro and regional coverage
- ✓Jim's Group satisfaction guarantee and insurance backing
- ✓Wide range of tree services including grinding, lopping, and root barrier
Cons
- ✗Franchisee quality can vary between operators
- ✗Slightly premium pricing compared to independent operators
Bottom Line
Verdict
DIY hire equipment is typically underpowered for stumps over 30cm and costs $200–$400 per day to hire. For a single small stump, DIY can be cost-effective. For medium or large stumps, or multiple stumps, professional grinding is almost always cheaper per stump and faster.
DIY is viable only for a single small stump under 30cm where you have the time and confidence to operate the machine safely. For anything larger, multiple stumps, difficult access, or where a clean finish is required, a professional stump grinding company will deliver better value and results.
Comparison FAQ
All Stumps Removed is cheaper on average in this comparison, but the right answer depends on your specific stump size, number of stumps, access requirements, and urgency.
Stump diameter, species, access difficulty, depth of grinding required, and whether backfill and mulch removal are included usually affect the total cost more than a blended average. Always confirm the stump diameter measurement method, depth included, and cleanup arrangement upfront.
DIY is viable only for a single small stump under 30cm where you have the time and confidence to operate the machine safely. For anything larger, multiple stumps, difficult access, or where a clean finish is required, a professional stump grinding company will deliver better value and results.