2026 Comparison
Jim's Fencing vs Simply Fencing
Comparing Jim's Fencing and Simply Fencing for fencing services in Australia. Which offers better value?
Winner
Simply Fencing
Best overall pick across installed price, local reach, and rating confidence.
Average Gap
$57
Difference in average pricing across overlapping fencing jobs.
Market Range
$15 - $600
The full low-to-high range across both providers.
Melbourne, VIC · Est. 2006
From
$65
Average
$204
Coverage
9 areas
Best for: Homeowners wanting convenient nationwide fencing with brand backing
Review Jim's FencingMelbourne, VIC · Est. 2014
From
$15
Average
$147
Coverage
7 areas
Best for: Melbourne homeowners wanting straightforward residential fencing
Review Simply FencingSide-by-Side Price Comparison
Compare the same fencing jobs so the cheaper quote is obvious at a glance.
| Service | Jim's Fencing | Simply Fencing | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Colorbond Fence (per m) | $100 | $92 | +$8 |
| Timber Paling Fence (per m) | $85 | $78 | +$7 |
| Pool Fence — Glass (per m) | $375 | $340 | +$35 |
| Pool Fence — Aluminium (per m) | $150 | N/A | — |
| Picket Fence (per m) | $115 | $100 | +$15 |
| Gate Installation | $400 | N/A | — |
| Retaining Wall + Fence (per m) | N/A | $250 | — |
| Old Fence Removal (per m) | N/A | $22 | — |
Pros & Cons
Jim's Fencing
Pros
- ✓National coverage across all states
- ✓Wide range of fencing types
- ✓Free measure and quote
- ✓Jim's Group satisfaction guarantee
Cons
- ✗Franchise pricing varies by location
- ✗Can be 10-20% more than independents
- ✗Quality depends on individual franchisee
Simply Fencing
WinnerPros
- ✓Competitive Melbourne pricing
- ✓Transparent flat-rate quoting
- ✓Old fence removal included in many quotes
- ✓Quick turnaround — often within a week
Cons
- ✗Melbourne and Geelong area only
- ✗No security or commercial fencing
- ✗Smaller team limits capacity
Bottom Line
Verdict
Simply Fencing is approximately 28% cheaper on average, while Jim's Fencing offers national coverage across all states. Simply Fencing is best for: Melbourne homeowners wanting straightforward residential fencing. Jim's Fencing is best for: Homeowners wanting convenient nationwide fencing with brand backing.
Choose Simply Fencing if budget is your priority. Choose Jim's Fencing if you value national coverage across all states.
Comparison FAQ
Simply Fencing is approximately 28% cheaper on average across comparable services. However, prices vary by service type — always compare the specific service you need.
Jim's Fencing services 9 areas (Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane...), while Simply Fencing services 7 areas (Melbourne CBD, Eastern Suburbs, Western Suburbs...).
Choose Simply Fencing if budget is your priority. Choose Jim's Fencing if you value national coverage across all states.