Carpet Laying/Compare/Carpet One vs Solomons Flooring

Quick Answer

Lower average budget fit: Carpet One. Best overall pick depends on whether you need the widest national coverage, competitive whole-house pricing or specialist regional knowledge.

Carpet One vs Solomons Flooring

Compare a member-owned cooperative flooring network with a WA-focused retailer offering in-home design services for mid-range residential carpet installation.

Lower average cost: Carpet One

Savings gap: $13/m²

Combined range: $33 - $310/m²

450 prices collectedUpdated March 2026Methodology

Trust badge

Verified pricing snapshot

Real collected price points, a visible update stamp, and a direct methodology path above the fold.

450 prices collected

Updated March 2026

Methodology

Prices Collected

450

quote points tracked

Updated

March 2026

current verification window

Method

Visible

jump straight to methodology

Carpet One

Sydney, NSW • Est. 1985

Winner

Average

$74/m²

Rating

4/5

Coverage

8 cities

Relative price position196 reviews

Homeowners and commercial buyers wanting competitive supply pricing from a member co-operative network, particularly for mid-range residential and commercial carpet tile projects.

View provider profile

Solomons Flooring

Perth, WA • Est. 1986

Average

$87/m²

Rating

4.1/5

Coverage

8 cities

Relative price position158 reviews

Perth and WA homeowners wanting a professional in-home measure and design service for mid-to-premium carpet supply and installation, particularly for renovation projects.

View provider profile

Verdict

Carpet One's cooperative buying model can deliver competitive supply pricing and broader national coverage including regional areas, while Solomons Flooring offers a strong in-home design and measure service particularly suited to renovation projects in Perth and WA. Both are mid-range providers with good residential carpet ranges.

Lower average budget fit: Carpet One. Recommendation: Choose Carpet One for competitive supply pricing through cooperative buying power, particularly in areas underserved by larger chains. Choose Solomons Flooring for WA renovation projects where an in-home design consultation and professional measure service add genuine value.

Best budget fit

Carpet One

Carpet One tracks roughly 15% lower on the average in this comparison, which matters most on bedroom and whole-house packages where the installed area is large.

Best confidence fit

Solomons Flooring

Solomons Flooring carries the stronger rating signal, which is useful when you care more about installer consistency, measure accuracy, and handover quality than shaving the final few dollars per square metre.

Best footprint

Carpet One

Carpet One covers 8 cities, making it the safer shortlist if you want the same network to quote multiple properties or family addresses in different metros.

Service	Carpet One	Solomons Flooring
Bedroom Carpet (Mid-Range)	$50/m²	$53/m²
Lounge Carpet (Mid-Range)	$56/m²	$59/m²
Wool Carpet (Premium)	$120/m²	N/A
Commercial Carpet Tiles	$68/m²	N/A
Whole House Carpet Package	N/A	$45/m²
Carpet Repair & Restretching	N/A	$190/m²

How quotes diverge

Carpet quotes spread for structural reasons: carpet grade, underlay, room complexity, uplift, and subfloor prep all move independently. Two providers can look close on an advertised bedroom rate and still land far apart once stairs, wardrobes, and disposal are priced properly.

Carpet One is more differentiated in Wool Carpet (Premium), Commercial Carpet Tiles, which may make it the better fit if those service lines are central to the project.

Solomons Flooring has clearer depth in Whole House Carpet Package, Carpet Repair & Restretching, which can justify a higher ticket if it avoids hiring a second specialist later.

Quote checklist

Ask for carpet grade, underlay specification, uplift and disposal, trims, and furniture moving as separate line items.

Confirm whether the quote assumes standard rectangular rooms or allows for stairs, wardrobes, landings, and pattern waste.

Get the provider to spell out what subfloor preparation is excluded so the cheapest quote does not become expensive after uplift.

For whole-house jobs, compare the installed total and the per-square-metre equivalent so package discounts are visible.

Methodology

Methodology: we compare tracked price lines, service-area depth, rating signals, and service mix across Carpet One and Solomons Flooring rather than treating every carpet quote as directly interchangeable.

Sample size: this comparison uses 450+ pricing, review, and coverage datapoints to keep the recommendation grounded in realistic installed-project conditions.

Last updated March 2026. We refresh provider comparisons when measured pricing, geographic reach, or service strengths change enough to affect the buyer recommendation.

Carpet laying comparison FAQ

Carpet One is the lower average-cost option in this comparison, with an average gap of about 15%. That usually matters most on whole-house carpet packages, where small per-square-metre differences compound quickly.

Carpet One is the better budget-led shortlist if your main goal is installed value across a large floor area, but Solomons Flooring may still be the smarter pick when quote clarity, installer coordination, or premium carpet range matters more than the headline rate.

No. Carpet One has clearer depth in Wool Carpet (Premium), Commercial Carpet Tiles, while Solomons Flooring stands out more in Whole House Carpet Package, Carpet Repair & Restretching. That matters when your project includes stairs, repair work, wool upgrades, or commercial-grade areas alongside standard rooms.

Compare carpet quality, underlay, uplift and disposal, subfloor preparation assumptions, transition trims, and whether furniture moving is included. Carpet quotes often look similar until you line up the installation scope properly.